Heartworm Disease, An Expert Opinion!
I thought I would forward this email from Dr. Jean Dodds, DVM and Hemopet about heartworm disease. It is copy written, just fyi. I think it answers some important questions that many of you ask, among them:
1. She does not recommend the 6 month injection, nor do I. It has some issues and is less safe IMO then current meds.
2. All you need to have heartworms in your area is 2 weeks of temps above 57 degrees F OR mosquitoes. We have both down valley.
Here is the email in it's entirety.
Heartworm: A real and present danger
As a practicing veterinarian for over 50 years, I have witnessed the spread of heartworm disease and experienced dogs and cats who have succumbed to its harsh and unforgiving effects. I believe that the excellent public awareness campaign over the past 30 years about heartworm prevention and medication distribution have done great good, but have actually led pet caregivers to a false sense of security that their pets will not get heartworm and subsequently a backlash to prescription preventatives.
The reality is heartworm disease has not been eradicated but has actually mutated. If you have not heard of any cases recently in your area, speak to your local shelter or rescue about how real and present the danger is. These organizations are dealing with it on the frontlines because of lack of funding to give preventives or to test for the disease.
History of Heartworm Disease and Prevention
The 1970’s saw heartworm disease spread from the Southeastern portion of the United States to the rest of the Continental United States, Hawaii and Canada. During the 1980’s and 1990’s, ivermectin (Heartgard) and milbemycin oxide (Interceptor) for dogs were introduced to the market, respectively. These preventatives – which have been through clinical trials – have kept this disease from reaching epidemic proportions. I understand the angst surrounding recent controversy regarding some preventatives. Please remember that pharmaceutical companies have years of respected reputation behind them with shareholders expecting them to be responsible. With that being said, everything we put in or on our bodies and our companion animal bodies can produce positive and negative effects from medications to food to water to topicals. Clinical trials allow us to measure the degree of the positive effects versus the negative. The negative effects are highly scrutinized. Before a drug is released, the negative effects are more than likely proportionately low compared to the positive. This is not a statement that all heartworm preventatives work for all companion animals or that a level of caution should not be exercised particularly for pets with autoimmune diseases.
Heartworm Disease Cause, Spread and Effects
Heartworm Disease is indirectly spread between animals via mosquitoes. A mosquito bites a “host” animal. Within 14 days, the microflaria molts in the mosquito who then passes it through another bite to another animal. Once the larvae reach the immature L5 stage in the animal, they will arrive in the heart’s right ventricle and neighboring blood vessels. The artery lining is damaged. The animal’s bodily response is inflammation of the artery, called endarteritis, and other inflammation in the area to try to heal the damage. Blood clots, aneurysms, and complete blockage of small blood vessels can occur. The blood tries to find a way to get to around the wormed areas, which results in complete and partial blockage of blood vessels, causing fluid to accumulate around these blood vessels in the lungs and reducing the effectiveness of the lungs’ ability to oxygenate the blood.
Heartworm Positive Diagnosis & Treatment in Dogs
Heartworm antigen tests and other tests have improved greatly over the past several years to detect the presence of heartworm earlier. However, it usually is 5-7 months before heartworm is detected after a dog is bitten.
Heartworm disease is directly related to how many worms are living inside the dog, the length of infection, the activity level of the dog, and the dog’s bodily response to heartworms. Oddly, highly active dogs will more than likely have a heavier burden of heartworms than less active dogs.
There are four classes (i.e. stages) of heartworm disease. The higher the class, the worse the disease and the more obvious the symptoms.
Class 1: No symptoms or mild symptoms such as an occasional cough.
Class 2: Mild to moderate symptoms such as an occasional cough and tiredness after moderate activity.
Class 3: General loss of body condition, a persistent cough, and tiredness after mild activity. Trouble breathing and signs of heart failure are common. For class 2 and 3 heartworm disease, heart and lung changes are usually seen on chest x-rays.
Class 4: Caval syndrome – a heavy worm burden that blood flows back to the heart is physically blocked by a large mass of worms. Caval syndrome is life-threatening and quick surgical removal of the heartworms from the pet’s heart is the only treatment option. The surgery is invasive and risky. Even with surgery, most dogs with caval syndrome die.
Not all dogs with heartworm disease develop caval syndrome. If left untreated, heartworm disease will progress and damage the dog’s heart, lungs, liver, and kidneys, eventually causing death. In essence, it is death by strangulation and complete organ failure.
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has approved two drugs for the treatment of heartworm disease in dogs. Both drugs contain arsenic and are effective at killing adult heartworms. Caparsolate Sodium (arsenamide sodium) is not currently manufactured or marketed in the United States. Immiticide (melarsomine hydrochloride) is given by a deep injection into the back muscles to treat dogs with stabilized class 1, 2, and 3 heartworm disease.
One drug, Advantage Multi for Dogs (imidacloprid and moxidectin), is FDA-approved to get rid of microfilariae in the bloodstream of heartworm-positive dogs.
Heartworm disease treatment can be potentially toxic to a dog’s body and can cause serious complications, such as life-threatening blood clots to the dog’s lungs. Treatment requires multiple visits to the veterinarian, bloodwork, x-rays, hospitalization, and a series of injections with Immiticide.
Quick Guide to Heartworm Preventives
•Prescription preventatives are preferred.
•Alternative, over-the-counter, non-prescriptive products OR unconventional approaches to heartworm prevention. The issue remains as follows: a negative heartworm test results does not prove that the alternative products work effectively, whereas only a positive heartworm infection result proves that they don’t work adequately.
•At the time of this writing, I do not support preventative, 6-month shots.
•Southeastern U.S. state residents should give preventatives year-round.
•Heartworm preventatives do not actually prevent mosquitoes from infecting your dog with heartworm larvae. These preventatives actually kill different stages of heartworm larvae that already have infected your dog. This is why we recommend giving heartworm during autumn months.
•Dogs, cats and ferrets should be tested annually for heartworm disease. If you live in a state that experiences cold weather months and choose to adopt a 6 month protocol, it is especially important to have your pet tested before the start of the heartworm preventative season.
•Overall, the temperature needs to be above 57 degrees for approximately two weeks and mosquitoes are prevalent.
•You can administer heartworm preventive every 45 days instead of every 30 days, but only if this interval is strictly adhered to. If it’s difficult to keep track with a reminder calendar, then your dog may need to stay on the medication every month.
•Half-doses are not recommended. Give the full prescription amount.
•Animals that have been taking monthly preventives for a relatively long time may develop subsequent product intolerance. Other preventatives should be sought out or rotated.
•Dogs affected with autoimmune diseases and their immediate relatives should receive only plain daily heartworm preventive (Dimmitrol = diethylcarmbazine). This drug can be found in Canada. For more information about dogs who have autoimmune diseases, chronic thyroid or liver conditions, please visit my blog post, “General Recommendations for Heartworm Preventives”.
•Trifexis is an oral preventative for fleas and heartworm. Trifexis contains spinosads which are contraindicated in epileptic or seizure prone dogs and should not be given to these dogs. Unfortunately, this is generally unknown and should be shared with your veterinarian, friends and family.
•Plain milbemycin oxime (Interceptor) is preferable as a heartworm preventive for certain groups of dogs, like sighthounds, smaller white breed dogs and those prone to seizures.
•Most Importantly: Discuss the right prescription preventative with your veterinarian.
W. Jean Dodds, DVM
Hemopet / NutriScan
11561 Salinaz Avenue
Garden Grove, CA 92843